2009 Honda Civic Hybrid

The 2009 Honda Civic Hybrid ranks 3 out of 35 Affordable Small Cars. This ranking is based on our analysis of 36 published reviews and test drives of the Honda Civic Hybrid, and our analysis of reliability and safety data.

The Civic Hybrid provides similar qualifications as the popular Toyota Prius while offering the conventional styling of a gas-engine sedan. But many reviewers report its around-town driving is weak, even for a hybrid vehicle. Even still, the Civic Hybrid is one of our top picks for 2009 U.S. News Best Cars for the Money.

The 2009 Honda Civic Hybrid compares well to both hybrid and small cars for its high quality, sleek design and fuel-sipping habits. Although many auto writers categorize the Civic Hybrid's performance as underwhelming, even among other small engine hybrids, the Civic Hybrid gets outstanding gas mileage -- second only to the popular Toyota Prius.

Chances are most people consider the Civic an alternative hybrid vehicle to the Prius rather than the other way around. The Prius' 2009 EPA rating is currently 48/45 mpg city/highway, its cabin is both upscale and roomy, and its exterior styling has become synonymous with "hybrid."

But the Civic Hybrid's distinction from the Prius continues to be its conventional styling. If that appeals to you, also consider the Toyota Camry Hybrid. In addition to its traditional Camry shape, this option is praised for the balanced drive offered by the four-cylinder engine and hybrid motor.

The gas-engine Honda Civic comes in a number of trims, as well as a performance Si trim and the two-door coupe, but the 2009 Civic Hybrid is only offered as a four-door sedan. The exterior has been slightly refreshed and new interior features have been added for 2009.

• "Honda's Civic hybrid is a good alternative for those who don't need Toyota Prius' distinctive styling to advertise their fuel saving heroics." -- USA Today
• "The Honda Civic Hybrid is one of the best hybrids available, with an affordable price, excellent driving dynamics, and fuel economy matched by few other models." -- Forbes
• "Whether your interest in hybrids is driven by political, environmental or financial considerations, the 2009 Honda Civic Hybrid allows you to address those issues in a vehicle that's just about as comfortable and stylish as a compact sedan can be with little sacrifice in drivability." -- Kelley Blue Book
• "Honda's reputation for practical economy is shown in the Civic Hybrid, well-built and simply designed to sip fuel. Interior tech options are usefully done, making this Honda a great commuter sedan." -- CNET
• "The Civic Hybrid's efficiency and environmental benefits are undeniable. Add in spaciousness, fun factor, and equipment level, and there's your value, folks. High, as in hybrid." -- About.com
• "Civic Hybrid drivers pay a price for being able to thumb their noses at Big Oil and help save the planet -- in higher purchase price and lower performance.